Teaching Clinical Reasoning and Critical Thinking in Psychology Graduate Courses: A Systematic Review

Titolo Rivista RICERCHE DI PSICOLOGIA
Autori/Curatori Tugce Elbir, Catia Cammeo, Francesca Cavallini, Antonella Marchetti, Davide Massaro
Anno di pubblicazione 2025 Fascicolo 2024/3
Lingua Inglese Numero pagine 24 P. 105-128 Dimensione file 0 KB
DOI 10.3280/rip2023oa18274
Il DOI è il codice a barre della proprietà intellettuale: per saperne di più clicca qui

Vedi l'articolo Scarica l'articolo open access

FrancoAngeli è membro della Publishers International Linking Association, Inc (PILA)associazione indipendente e non profit per facilitare (attraverso i servizi tecnologici implementati da CrossRef.org) l’accesso degli studiosi ai contenuti digitali nelle pubblicazioni professionali e scientifiche

Introduction: There are many studies and reviews that investigate the most functional ways of explicitly teaching clinical reasoning skills in more traditionally healthcare areas such as medicine and nursing, hypothesizing that reducing the gap between theory and practice could guarantee continuity in the quality of care provided to patients.Clinical reasoning and critical thinking are aspects that in clinical practice guide the psychologist in diagnosis and intervention. However, in the psychological field there is a lack of experimental studies that address the issue of direct or explicit teaching of these skills.This systematic review study sought to investigate, via a systematic review, whether there is an association between the teaching methodology and the student’s improvement in their critical analyses and clinical reasoning skills.Statement of the Problem: Despite the importance for clinicians, the interest of researchers and academics is quite recent. Teaching of clinical reasoning is, on the contrary, more common in medicine and nursing sectors. Methodology: Articles published from 2004 until 2023 within PubMed (National Center for Biotechnology Information, NCBI), Web of Science (Core Collection, Clarivate Analytics), Scopus (Elsevier), EBSCO, Scielo, and Psychinfo databases were searched through the following keywords: Critical Thinking - Clinical Reasoning; Problem Based Learning - Case Based Learning; Teaching Methods - Teaching Strategies; Learning Strategies - Clinical Learning; University; Intervention - Training; Psychology; Psychology Students.Results: Theoretical and practical implications to teach clinical reasoning and critical thinking in the psychological field were discussed, including recommendations for designing researches aimed at investigating the impact of the different methodologies, as well as the possibility of including education in critical thinking within the different levels of training dedicated to psychologists.Conclusion: The collected studies presented methodologies that, although different, significantly promoted the improvement of critical thinking in university students, demonstrating that it is “possible” to transfer this complex skill.

Introduction: There are many studies and reviews that investigate the most functional ways of explicitly teaching clinical reasoning skills in more traditionally healthcare areas such as medicine and nursing, hypothesizing that reducing the gap between theory and practice could guarantee continuity in the quality of care provided to patients.Clinical reasoning and critical thinking are aspects that in clinical practice guide the psychologist in diagnosis and intervention. However, in the psychological field there is a lack of experimental studies that address the issue of direct or explicit teaching of these skills.This systematic review study sought to investigate, via a systematic review, whether there is an association between the teaching methodology and the student’s improvement in their critical analyses and clinical reasoning skills.Statement of the Problem: Despite the importance for clinicians, the interest of researchers and academics is quite recent. Teaching of clinical reasoning is, on the contrary, more common in medicine and nursing sectors. Methodology: Articles published from 2004 until 2023 within PubMed (National Center for Biotechnology Information, NCBI), Web of Science (Core Collection, Clarivate Analytics), Scopus (Elsevier), EBSCO, Scielo, and Psychinfo databases were searched through the following keywords: Critical Thinking - Clinical Reasoning; Problem Based Learning - Case Based Learning; Teaching Methods - Teaching Strategies; Learning Strategies - Clinical Learning; University; Intervention - Training; Psychology; Psychology Students.Results: Theoretical and practical implications to teach clinical reasoning and critical thinking in the psychological field were discussed, including recommendations for designing researches aimed at investigating the impact of the different methodologies, as well as the possibility of including education in critical thinking within the different levels of training dedicated to psychologists.Conclusion: The collected studies presented methodologies that, although different, significantly promoted the improvement of critical thinking in university students, demonstrating that it is “possible” to transfer this complex skill.

Parole chiave:; Clinical reasoning; critical thinking; clinical learning; psychology students; teaching methods

  1. Abrami, P. C., Bernard, R. M., Borokhovski, E., Wade, A., Surkes, M. A., Tamim, R., & Zhang, D..(2008). Instructional Interventions Affecting Critical Thinking Skills and Dispositions: A Stage 1 Meta-Analysis. Review of Educational Research, 78(4), 1102-34. DOI: 10.3102/0034654308326084
  2. Aglen, B. (2016). Pedagogical strategies to teach bachelor students evidence-based practice: A systematic review. Nurse education today, 36, 255-263. DOI: 10.1016/j.nedt.2015.08.025
  3. Ahlfeldt, S., Mehta, S., & Sellnow, T. (2005). Measurement and analysis of student engagement in university classes where varying levels of PBL methods of instruction are in use. Higher Education Research & Development, 24(1), 5-20. DOI: 10.1080/0729436052000318541
  4. Al Rumayyan, A., Ashmed, N., Al Subait, R., Al Ghamdi, G., Mahzari, M. M., Mohamed, T.A., Rotgans, J. I., Donmez, M., Mamede, S., & Schmidt, H. G. (2018). Teaching clinical reasoning through hypothetico-deduction is (slightly) better than self explanation in tutorial groups: An experimental study. Perspective on Medical Education, 7(2), 93-99. DOI: 10.1007/s40037-018-0409-x
  5. Andrews, J. J. W., Syeda, M. M. (2016). Clinical reasoning in School Psychology: From Assessment to Intervention. Canadian Journal of School Psychology, 32(1), 3-15. DOI: 10.1177/082957351665993
  6. Barrows, H.S. (1996). Problem-based learning in medicine and beyond: a brief overview. New Directions for Teaching and Learning, 68, 3-12. DOI: 10.1002/tl.37219966804
  7. Bensley, D. A. (1998). Critical thinking in psychology: A unified skills approach. Pacific Grove, CA: Thomson Brooks/Cole Publishing Co.
  8. Bensley, D. A., & Baxter, C. (2006). The critical thinking in psychology test. Unpublished manuscript. Frostburg State University, Frostburg, MD.
  9. Bensley, D. A., Crowe, D. S., Bernhardt, P., Buckner, C., & Allman, A. L. (2010). Teaching and assessing critical thinking skills for argument analysis in psychology. Teaching of Psychology, 37(2), 91-96. DOI: 10.1080/00986281003626656
  10. Behar-Horenstein, L. S., & Niu, L. (2011). Teaching critical thinking skills in higher education: A review of the literature. Journal of College Teaching & Learning (TLC), 8(2), 25-41. DOI: 10.19030/tlc.v8i2.3554
  11. Bonwell, C. C., & Eison, J. A. (1991). Active Learning: Creating Excitement in the Classroom. ASHE-ERIC Higher Education Report. School of Education and Human Development, George Washington University.
  12. Burbach, B., Barnason, S., & Thompson, S. A. (2015). Using “think aloud” to capture clinical reasoning during patient simulation. International journal of nursing education scholarship, 12(1), 1-7. DOI: 10.1515/ijnes-2014-0044
  13. Cacioppo, J. T., & Petty, R. E. (1982). The need for cognition. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 42(1), 116-131. DOI: 10.1037/0022-3514.42.1.116
  14. Cammeo C., Prestera G., Massaro D., Marchetti A., & Cavallini, F. (2022). Teaching clinical reasoning to psychology students: an exploratory study on the potential of a podcast training. Journal of Clinical and Developmental Psychology, 4(2-3), 1-15. DOI: 10.13129/2612-4033/0110-3394
  15. Campbell, C. G., & Oswald, B. R. (2018). Promoting critical thinking through service learning: A home-visiting case study. Teaching of Psychology, 45(2), 193-199. DOI: 10.1177/0098628318762933
  16. Cavallini, F., Sacchetti, M. C., Vascelli, L., & Artoni, V. (2019). The academic network in the field of psychology as a strategy of innovation for nonprofit enterprises. Journal of Clinical and Developmental Psychology, 1(2), 39-48. DOI: 10.6092/2612-4033/0110-2102
  17. Chan, Z. C. (2016). A systematic review on critical thinking in medical education. International journal of adolescent medicine and health, 30(1). DOI: 10.1515/ijamh-2015-0117
  18. Choi, S., Oh, S., Lee, D. H., & Yoon, H. S. (2020). Effects of reflection and immediate feedback to improve clinical reasoning of medical students in the assessment of dermatologic conditions: a randomised controlled trial. BMC Medical Education, 20, 146. DOI: 10.1186/s12909-020-02063-y
  19. Delany, C., Kameniar, B., Lysk, J., & Vaughan, B. (2020). “Starting from a higher place”: linking Habermas to teaching and learning clinical reasoning in the emergency medicine context. Advances in Health Sciences Education, 25(4), 809-824. DOI: 10.1007/s10459-020-09958-x
  20. Dillenbourg, P. (1999). What do you mean by collaborative learning? In Dillenbourg, P. (Ed.), Collaborative-Learning: Cognitive and Computational Approaches. Oxford: Elsevier, (pp. 1-19).
  21. Duncker, K. (1926). A qualitative (experimental and theoretical) study of productive thinking solving of comprehensible problems. Pedagogical Seminary and Journal of Genetic Psychology, 33, 642-708. DOI: 10.1080/08856559.1926.10533052
  22. Durning, S. J., Trowbridge, R. L., & Schuwirth, L. (2019). Clinical Reasoning and Diagnostic Error. A Call to Merge Two Worlds to Improve Patient Care. Academic Medicine: Volume Publish Ahead of Print Issue. DOI: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000003041
  23. Ennis, R. H., Millman, J., & Tomko, T. N. (1985). Cornell Critical Thinking Tests, Level X and Level Z manual (3th Eds). Pacific Grove, CA: Midwest Publications.
  24. Ennis, R. H., Millman, J., & Tomko, T. N. (2004). Cornell Critical Thinking Tests, Level X and evel Z manual (4th Eds). Seaside, CA. Critical Thinking Company.
  25. Faucher, C. (2011). Differentiating the Elements of Clinical Thinking. Optometric Education, 36(3), 140-145. https://journal.opted.org/articles/Volume_36_Number_3_CriticalThinking.pdf.
  26. Fitch, P., & Steinke, P. (2013). Tools for assessing cognitive outcomes of experiential learning. NCA HLC Annual Conference on Quality in Higher Education.
  27. https://departments.central.edu/psychology/files/2011/07/HLC-2013-Paper-Fitch-Steinke.pdf.
  28. Guerrero, J. (2019). Practice Rationale Care Model: The Art and Science of Clinical Reasoning, Decision Making and Judgment in the Nursing Process. Open Journal of Nursing, 9, 88. DOI: 10.4236/ojn.2019.92008
  29. Handelsman, M. M., Briggs, W. L., Sullivan, N., & Towler, A. (2005). A measure of college student course engagement. The Journal of Educational Research, 98, 184-192. DOI: 10.3200/JOER.98.3.184-192
  30. Haw, J. (2011). Improving psychological critical thinking in Australian university students. Australian Journal of Psychology, 63(3), 150-153. DOI: 10.1111/j.1742-9536.2011.00018.x
  31. Hildenbrand, K. J., & Schultz, J. A. (2012). Development of a rubric to improve critical thinking. Athletic Training Education Journal, 7(3), 86-94. DOI: 10.5608/070386
  32. Huhn, K., Gilliland, S. J., Black, L. L., Wainwright, S. F., & Christensen, N. (2019). Clinical Reasoning in Physical Therapy: A Concept Analysis. Physical Therapy, 99(4), 440-456. DOI: 10.1093/ptj/pzy148
  33. Ihm, J., Shin, Y., & Seo, D. G. (2020). Did Clinical reasoning and Knowledge Questions During Team-based Learning Enhance Dental Students’ Performance in Esthetic Dentistry?. Journal of Dental Education, 84(4), 495-501. DOI: 10.21815/JDE.019.19
  34. Joice, V. C. (2013). Critical Thinking Versus Clinical Reasoning Versus Clinical Judgment: Differential Diagnosis. Nurse Educator, 38(1), 34-36. DOI: 10.1097/NNE.0b013e318276dfbe
  35. Karantzas, G. C, Avery, M. R., Macfarlane, S., Mussap, A., Tooley, G., Hazelwood, Z., & Fitness, J. (2013). Enhancing critical analysis and problem-solving skills inundergraduate psychology: An evaluation of a collaborative learning and problem-based learning approach. Australian Journal of Psychology, 65, 38-45. DOI: 10.1111/ajpy.12009
  36. Kosior, K., Wall, T., & Ferrero, S. (2019). The role of metacognition in teaching clinical reasoning: Theory to practice. Education in The Health Professions, 2(2), 108-114. DOI: 10.4103/EHP.EHP_14_19
  37. Koufidis, C., Manninen, K., Nieminen, J., Wohlin, M., & Silén, C. (2020). Grounding judgement in context: A conceptual learning model of clinical reasoning. Medical education, 54(11), 1019-1028. DOI: 10.1111/medu.1422
  38. Lapkin, S., Levett-Jones, T., Bellchambers, H., & Fernandez, R. (2010). Effectiveness of patient simulation manikins in teaching clinical reasoning skills to undergraduatenursing students: A systematic review. Clinical simulation in nursing, 6(6), e207-e222. DOI: 10.1016/j.ecns.2010.05.005
  39. Lawson, T. J. (1999). Assessing psychological critical thinking as a learning outcome for psychology majors. Teaching of Psychology, 26, 207-209. DOI: 10.1207/S15328023TOP260311
  40. Li, S., Eang, Y., Xue, J., Zhao, N., & Zhu, T. (2020). The Impact of COVID-19 Epidemic Declaration on Psychological Consequences: A Study on Active Weibo Users. International Journal Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(6), 2032. DOI: 10.3390/ijerph17062032
  41. Mason, A., Locke, R., Lusznat, R. M., Coles, C., & Masding, M. G. (2020). How Do Contexts Affect Physicians’ Clinical Reasoning? A Narrative Review. MedEdPublish, 9(1), 32. DOI: 10.15694/mep.2020.000032.1
  42. Methley, A. M., Campbell, S., Chew-Graham, C., McNally, R., & Cheraghi-Sohi, S. (2014). PICO, PICOS and SPIDER: a comparison study of specificity and sensitivity in three search tools for qualitative systematic reviews. BMC Health Services Research, 14, 579. DOI: 10.1186/s12913-014-0579-0
  43. Ministero della Salute (2018) Rapporto salute mentale. Analisi dei dati del Sistema informativo per la salute mentale (SISM). Available online: http://www.salute.gov.it/portale/documentazione/p6_2_2_1.jsplingua=italiano&id=2932.
  44. Muehlenkamp, J. J., Weiss, N., & Hansen, M. (2015). Problem-based learning for introductory psychology: Preliminary supporting evidence. Scholarship of Teaching and Learning in Psychology, 1(2), 125. DOI: 10.1037/stl0000027
  45. Mutter, M. K., Martindale, J. R., Shah, N., Gusic, M. E., & Wolf, S. J. (2020). Case-Based Teaching: Does the Addition of High-Fidelity Simulation Make a Difference in Medical Students’ Clinical Reasoning Skills?. Medical Science Educator, 30, 307-313. DOI: 10.1007/s40670-019-00904-0
  46. Norman, G. R. (2000). The epistemology of clinical reasoning: perspectives from philosophy, psychology, and neuroscience. Academic Medicine, 75(10), S127-S133. DOI: 10.1097/00001888-200010001-00041
  47. O’Hare, L., & McGuinness, C. (2004). Skills and attributes developed by psychology undergraduates: Ratings by undergraduates, post graduates, academic psychologists and professional practitioners. Psychology Learning and Teaching, 4, 35-42. DOI: 10.2304/plat.2004.4.1.35
  48. Oliveira, L. B. D., Díaz, L. J. R., Carbogim, F. D. C., Rodrigues, A. R. B., & Püschel, V. A. D. A. (2016). Effectiveness of teaching strategies on the development of critical thinking in undergraduate nursing students: a meta-analysis. Revista da Escola de Enfermagem da USP, 50(2), 355-364. DOI: 10.1590/S0080-623420160000200023
  49. Payan-Carreira, R., Cruz, G., Papathanasiou, I. V., Fradelos, E., & Jiang, L. (2019). The effectiveness of critical thinking instructional strategies in health professions education: a systematic review. Studies in Higher Education, 44(5), 829-843. DOI: 10.1080/03075079.2019.1586330
  50. Pelaccia, T., Plotnick, L. H., Audétat, M. C., Nendaz, M., Lubarsky, S., Torabi, N., Thomas, A., Young, M., & Dory, V. (2020). A Scoping Review of Physicians’ Clinical Reasoning in Emergency Departments. Annals of Emergency Medicine, 75(2), 206-217. DOI: 10.1016/j.annemergmed.2019.06.023
  51. Penningroth, S. L., Despain, L. H., & Gray, M. J. (2007). A course designed to improve psychological critical thinking. Teaching of Psychology, 34(3), 153-157. DOI: 10.1080/00986280701498509
  52. Pierce, C., Corral, J., Aagaard, E., Harnke, B., Irby, D. M., & Stickrath, C. (2020). A BEME realist synthesis review of the effectiveness of teaching strategies used in the clinical setting on the development of clinical skills among health professionals: BEME Guide No. 61 [published online ahead of print, 2020 Jan 21]. Medical Teacher, 1-12. DOI: 10.1080/0142159X.2019.1708294
  53. Pramila-Savukoski, S., Juntunen, J., Tuomikoski, A. M., Kaariainen, M., Tomietto, M., Kaucic, B. M., Filej, B., Riklikiene, O., Vizcaya-Moreno, M. F., Perez-Canaveras, R. M., De Raeve, P., & Mikkonen, K. (2019). Mentors’ self-assessed competence in mentoring nursing students in clinical practice: A systematic review of quantitative studies. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 29(5-6), 684-705. DOI: 10.1111/jocn.15127
  54. Richmond, A., Cooper, N., Gay, S., Atiomo, W., & Patel, R. (2020). The student is key: A realist review of educational interventions to develop analytical and non‐analytical clinical reasoning ability. Medical education, 54(8), 709-719. DOI: 10.1111/medu.14137
  55. Robertson, D. M., (2012). Critical thinking and clinical reasoning in new graduate occupational therapists: a phenomenological study. Available from OpenAIR@RGU. [online]. Available from: http://openair.rgu.ac.uk.
  56. Roschelle, J., & Teasley, S. (1995). The construction of shared knowledge in collaborative problem solving. In C. E. O’Malley (Eds.), Computer supported collaborative learning (pp. 69-97). Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-85098-1_5
  57. Frank, J. R., Snell, L., & Sherbino J. CanMEDS (2015). Physician Competency. Framework. Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (2015). Available online: http://www.royalcollege.ca/rcsite/canmeds/canmeds-framework-e.
  58. Royce, C. S., Hayes, M. M., & Schwartzstein, R. M. (2019). Teaching Critical Thinking: A Case for Instruction in Cognitive Biases to Reduce Diagnostic Errors and Improve Patient Safety. Academic Medicine, 94(2), 187-194. DOI: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000002518
  59. Rutter, P. M., & Harrison, T. (2020). Differential diagnosis in pharmacy practice: Time to adopt clinical reasoning and decision making. Research in Social and Administrative Pharmacy, 16(10), 1483-1486. DOI: 10.1016/j.sapharm.2020.02.020
  60. Shin, H. S. (2019). Reasoning processes in clinical reasoning: from the perspective of cognitive psychology. Korean Journal of Medical Education, 31(4), 299-308. DOI: 10.3946/kjme.2019.140
  61. Solon, T. (2007). Generic Critical Thinking Infusion and Course Content Learning in Introductory Psychology. Journal of Instructional Psychology, 34(2), 95-109.
  62. Sternberg, R. J., Halpern, D. F. (2020). Critical Thinking in Psychology, 2th (Eds). Promoting Critical Thinking by Teaching, or Taking, Psychology Courses, 5, pp. 103-124. Cambridge University Press.
  63. Cumming, A., Cumming, A., & Ross, M. (2007). The Tuning Project for Medicine-learning outcomes for undergraduate medical education in Europe. Medical teacher, 29(7), 636-641. Consulted on 12 January 2020. DOI: 10.1080/01421590701721721
  64. Torre, D., Durning, S. J., Rencic, J., Lang, V., Holmboe, E., & Daniel, M. (2020). Widening the lens on teaching and assessing clinical reasoning: from “in the head” to “out in the world”. Official Journal of the Society to Improve Diagnosis in Medicine (SIDM), 7(3), 181-190. DOI: 10.1515/dx-2019-0098
  65. Vidyarthi, A., Lek, N., Chan, K., & Kamei, R. (2016). Experiences with a clinical reasoning and evidence-based medicine course. The clinical teacher, 13(1), 52-57. DOI: 10.1111/tct.12362
  66. Wentworth, D. K., & Whitmarsh, L. (2017). Thinking Like a Psychologist Introductory Psychology Writing Assignments: Encouraging Critical Thinking and Resisting Plagiarism. Teaching of Psychology, 44(4), 335-341. DOI: 10.1177/0098628317727909
  67. Young, M., Thomas, A., Gordon, D., Gruppen, L., Lubarsky, S., Rencic, J., Ballard, T., Holmboe, E., Da Silvia, A., Ratcliffe, T., Schuwirth, L., & Durning, S. J. (2019). The terminology of clinical reasoning in health professions education: Implications and considerations. Journal of Medical Teacher, 41(11), 1277-1284. DOI: 10.1080/0142159X.2019.1635686
  68. Young, M. E., Thomas, A., Lubarsky, S., Gordon, D., Gruppen, L. D., Rencic, J., Ballard, T., Holmboe, E., Da Silva, A., Ratcliffe, T., Schuwirth, L., Dory, V., & Durning, S. J. (2020). Mapping clinical reasoning literature across the health professions: a scoping review. BMC Medical Education, 20, 107. DOI: 10.1186/s12909-020-02012-9

Tugce Elbir, Catia Cammeo, Francesca Cavallini, Antonella Marchetti, Davide Massaro, Teaching Clinical Reasoning and Critical Thinking in Psychology Graduate Courses: A Systematic Review in "RICERCHE DI PSICOLOGIA" 3/2024, pp 105-128, DOI: 10.3280/rip2023oa18274